Luxury Valley Homes Arizona Real Estate Blog

2nd Amendment: Should it be Protected? - Supreme Court May Say No

2nd Amendment: This is a topic that has been of interest over the past few years and we find that today it is more important than ever. While vacating the 2nd Amendment would require the other 50 states to agree it can and has been attack on several fronts. These attacks have come from the legislative, and executive branch of our government.

2nd Amendment

2nd Amendment

Two of the most notable attacks that found their way to the Supreme Court for an opinion were McDonald v. Chicago, and District of Columbia v. Heller (2008). In essence they dealt with constitution gun rights for the individual citizens. They were upheld with a 5-4 vote by the Supreme Court.

The 5-4 vote at the Supreme Court level is a "CRITICAL FACTOR". Why is that you ask?

Let's start by identifying the current members of SCOTUS. They are as follows:


2nd Amendment83 - Ruth Bader Ginsburg (March 15, 1933) Appointed by Clinton
80 - Anthony Kennedy (July 23, 1936) Appointed by Reagan
78 - Stephen Breyer (August 15, 1938) Appointed by Clinton
68 - Clarence Thomas (June 23, 1948) Appointed by GHW Bush
66 - Samuel Ailito (April 1, 1950) - Appointed by GW Bush
62 - Sonia Sotomayor (June 25, 1954) Appointed by Obama
61 - John Roberts (January 27, 1955) Appointed by G.W Bush
56 - Elena Kagen (April 28, 1960) Appointed by Obama

Given the ages of these members it is possible that between one, and four will retire during the next term of the Presidency making these slots available for new appointments.

Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. was 90 when he retired from the Supreme Court. That would suggest that it is possible that new appointments could have an impact on decisions for decades.

The question becomes so what? Looking at many of the decisions during the past few years the liberals on the Supreme Court have made rulings not based on the interpretation of constitutional law but based on opinion, associated with ideology.

A detail study analysis on decisions show that the liberal decisions were based more on their jurisprudential philosophies as well as their ideological leanings, personal attitudes, values, political philosophies, or policy preferences. [Source: Bayesian Model on cases by Justice since 1937]

There have been end around tactics used to attack the 2nd amendment.

CNN News on December 23, 2014 reported that U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry signs the Arms Trade Treaty as Under Secretary-General for Legal Affairs Miguel Serpa Soares looks on during the 68th session of the United Nations General Assembly at U.N. headquarters, Wednesday, Sept. 25, 2013.

The enforceability of this would only apply to those that signed the treaty. One of many countries that would not sign the treaty, and is one of the largest arms sellers - Russia.

When Secretary of State John Kerry signed the Arms Trade Treaty (ATT) on behalf of the U.S. in September 2013, he declared that it achieved three important priorities for the U.S. – “a more peaceful world,” “a higher level of security” and “protection of human rights.”

In reality this would weaken our ability as a sovereign nation to rule by our constitution with grave impacts on our 2nd amendment. Fortunately, we had enough Senators that opposed the treaty and it did not become effective.

The National Rifle Association accused Clinton of trying to take away the right to own a firearm protected under the Second Amendment. In a speech at the Republican National Convention, Chris Cox, executive director of the lobbying arm of the National Rifle Association, said that a Clinton-influenced Supreme Court would “[mean] your right to own a firearm is gone.” With new appointees to the Supreme Court by Clinton, this would not be a stretch.

Instead, I personally would like the following:

  • A Concealed-Carry Permit Granted by Any State Should Be Given Full Faith and Credit by All Other States.

While there is objections to this by many, studies by both private, and government have concluded the following:

  • According to the FBI, the total U.S. homicide rate has fallen by over half since 1980, and the gun homicide rate has fallen along with it.
  • While gun ownership doubled in the late 20th century, Americans are safer today from violent crime, including gun homicide, than they have been at any time since the mid-1960s.
  • The vast majority of gun-related deaths are suicides, not homicides.

The reasons for support are many, and to long to list in this article but the question remains - Should the 2nd Amendment be Protected?

Biographies of Current Supreme Court Justices

Comment balloon 3 commentsJane & Jeff Daley, PhD • September 16 2016 04:39PM
2nd Amendment: Should it be Protected? - Supreme Court May Say No
2nd Amendment: This is a topic that has been of interest over the past few years and we find that today it is more important than ever. While vacating the 2nd Amendment would require the other 50 states to agree it can and has been attack on several… more
Baby Boomers: Finding Freedom In Retirement - WinfieldEstates. com
Baby Boomers - Within the next five years, Baby Boomers are projected to have the largest household growth of any other generation during that same time period, according to the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard. Let’s take a look at why…… more
Number of Homes Sold: Yesterday - Did Yours?
Number of Homes Sold - There are some homeowners that have been waiting for months to get a price they hoped for when they originally listed their house for sale. The only thing they might want to consider is… If it hasn't sold yet, maybe it's… more
Paperwork Mass: Why So Much Paperwork to get a Mortgage
Paperwork Mass - We are often asked why there is so much paperwork mandated by the bank for a mortgage loan application when buying a home today. It seems that the bank needs to know everything about us and requires three separate sources to… more
Real Estate Values: Today Compared to Pre-2008 Peak
Real Estate Values - This housing market has many people talking about home values; where they are and where they are headed. It’s also interesting to look back and see how home prices compare to values prior to the housing crisis. Every quarter,… more
Luxury Home Sales: The Impact of The Stock Market
Luxury Home Sales - In a recent article, CoreLogic looked at the correlation between stocks and the sales of upper-end properties ($1 Million plus sales price). The report revealed: “ The powerful ‘wealth effects’ generated by the rapid rise in… more
Mortgage Myths: 2 That May Be Holding Back Buyers – Scottsdale Homes
Mortgage Myths - Fannie Mae’s study revealed that Americans are misinformed about what is required to qualify for a mortgage when purchasing a home. ¹ Breaking The Mortgage Myths Fannie Mae Key Survey Findings There is a significant lack of… more
Bang for Your Buck: States That Give You More For Less
Bang for Your Buck Highlights from Graphic Thinking of moving across the country? How far will your money take you? The majority of states in the Midwest and South offer a lower cost of living compared to Northeast and Western states. The ‘Biggest… more
Your Home Equity: How Does Rising Prices Impact It?
Your Home Equity - Yesterday, we shared the results of the latest Home Price Expectation Survey by Pulsenomics. One of the big takeaways from the survey is that over the next five years, home prices will appreciate 3. 5% per year on average, and… more
Homeownership: Old Millennials Are Taking The Plunge
Homeownership Highlights of Graphic Old Millennials’ are defined as 25-36 year olds according to the US Census Bureau. According to NAR’s latest Profile of Home Buyers & Sellers, the median age of all first-time home buyers is 31 years… more